OrphenCoB1989 (Wednesday 7th of January 2009 03:40:46 PM)

sorry I should correct my comment, in my opinion, she's a bitch. a singer that doesnt travel with the rest of the band? and litterally sais she was only a guest singer?! sounds bitchy to me... these things were pretty clear facts I think. Since, as far as I know, neither of them said they werent true... im not doubting her vocal talents she is a great singer and she always will be, but she should stay solo. And I still think Anette improved alot of songs, and others are better with Tarja.

16syd (Wednesday 7th of January 2009 01:15:00 PM)

do you know what really happened in the band and this gives you the right to judge tarja? do you know their real motive? maybe what tuomas said was not true maybe what tarja said is not true. we will never know what really happened there cause they aren`t stupid to say the whole truth or the truth at all. ofcourse we must face the truth tarja will never be back to nightwish, yet she does a great job alone too...but anette was never the best choice for nightwish.they could`ve found someone better

fabriziodejatedewear (Wednesday 7th of January 2009 11:52:04 AM)

mala version, no me digan que no... :(

emmmmmmmmmmelie (Wednesday 7th of January 2009 06:13:25 AM)

darkbeelzebub, i totally agree with you.. I'm tired of people who says that Tarja was Nightwish and so on.. she was a singer in the band and no longer.. take it or leave it

jcdusmel (Monday 5th of January 2009 04:40:09 AM)

I was in the field duing this show.... that was grate! Wacken and Nightwish rock's!!!!

DaRkBeeLzEbuB (Friday 2nd of January 2009 11:14:32 AM)

Oh man, Nightwish is NOT Anette or Tarja. Understand this! I like both versions.

0dalomismoweon0 (Saturday 3rd of January 2009 08:24:34 PM)

Nice Comment!! Tarje was the singer, Anette is the new singer, Diferent singer, but not a diferent band

moira244 (Friday 2nd of January 2009 08:48:38 AM)

Cierto que no suena como el Nightwish original, pero si tenemos en cuenta que a la pobre chavala la han hecho sustituir a una soprano profesional... No lo hace nada mal, incluso da un enfoque nuevo a algunas canciones, claro que como fueras fan de la canción original, estás jodido. De todas formas, está claro que si el grupo se ha separado no es culpa suya, ella sólo intenta hacer su trabajo lo mejor que puede. No entiendo qué sentido tiene que algunos aún la comparen con Tarja...

umbralkey (Sunday 4th of January 2009 09:53:40 PM)

una pekeña correccion a tu comentario Soprano es un rango vocal, no un tipo de voz, tanto tarja como anette tienen un rango de soprano, el punto es que ambas tienen una preparacion distinta y un enfoque distinto, en este caso tarja tiene un enfoque "clasico" y anette un enfoque "popular" :) saludos :)

umbralkey (Thursday 1st of January 2009 04:05:12 PM)

nightwish nunca fue metal gotico =)